I will join my kids this week for our annual pumpkin carving in preparation for Halloween.
According to a LifeWay poll, however, I am among a slight minority (49 percent) of evangelical Christians who participate fully in Halloween activities.
Fifty-one percent of evangelical Christians either avoid Halloween completely (28 percent) or avoid the “pagan elements” (23 percent).
As a historian, I find this poll disappointing.
Not because I think everyone should participate in Halloween (I don’t really care that much), but because the very wording of the poll – “When you consider the pagan elements of Halloween, which is closer to your attitude?” – conveys that Halloween is still mostly regarded as a non-Christian holiday.
Yes, Halloween has similarities with (possibly accretions from) Samhain, the Celtic end-of-summer celebration. But this does not make it a pagan holiday.
As historian Nicholas Rogers, author of “Halloween: From Pagan Ritual to Party Night,” states, “If Samhain imparted to Halloween a supernatural charge and an intrinsic liminality, it did not offer much in the way of actual ritual practices, save in its fire rites. Most of these developed in conjunction with the medieval holy days of All Souls’ and All Saints’ day.”
Indeed, most of the traditions we associate with Halloween are medieval or early modern in their origin – not “pagan.”
First, we know that festivals commemorating saints (All Hallows Eve) existed in Europe by 800 A.D.
We also know that these festivals were not created to supplant previously existing pagan rituals.
The Irish world (which provides the origin of the Celtic feast Samhain) celebrated a feast for saints in April while the Germanic world (which did not recognize Samhain) celebrated in November.
What does this tell us? It tells us, Rogers explains, that the actual chronology of Halloween “contradicts the widely held view that the November date was chosen to Christianize the festival of Samhain.”
In fact, John Mirk’s “Festial” (the most popular orthodox sermon compilation in late medieval England) actually explains the origins of All Hallows Eve.
Pope Boniface IV converted the Roman Pantheon into a Christian church dedicated to saints and martyrs during the 7th century. This day was then commemorated as All Saints’ Day.
While Mirk’s story does tell about the Christian appropriation of a pagan temple, his narrative is firmly situated in a Christian event (the dedication of a new church) far removed from the Celtic world of Samhain.
From this medieval perspective, Halloween is a celebration of Christian triumph over paganism, rather than a pagan holiday masquerading as Christian.
Second, in the words of historian Ronald Hutton, we have “no idea” about what actually happened during the Celtic celebration of Samhain.
Despite what you may have read from Pat Robertson’s website or from James Frazer’s “The Golden Bough” (a classic social anthropology study from 1890 that explores the parallels between Christianity and ancient mythology), we have very little evidence about the actual practices of Celtic people or their festivals.
Rogers argues that Frazer’s description of Samhain in “The Golden Bough” anachronistically projected medieval traditions onto the past.
As Rogers writes, “There is no hard evidence that Samhain was specifically devoted to the dead or to ancestor worship.”
In fact, scholars really aren’t sure what Celtic culture entails. Some are even questioning the reality of the Celts as a coherent people group.
Let me say it again: We have very little evidence about the actual festivals of the people we know as Celts.
It is the medieval Christian festivals of All Saints’ and All Souls’ that provide our firmest foundation for Halloween.
From emphasizing dead souls (both good and evil), to decorating skeletons, lighting candles for processions, building bonfires to ward off evil spirits, organizing community feasts and even encouraging carnival practices like costumes, the medieval and early modern traditions of “Hallowtide” fit well with our modern holiday.
So what does this all mean?
It means that when we celebrate Halloween, we are definitely participating in a tradition with deep historical roots.
But, while those roots are firmly situated in the medieval Christian past, their historical connection to “paganism” is rather more tenuous.
Beth Allison Barr is associate professor of history at Baylor University and a resident scholar at Baylor’s Institute for Studies of Religion. A version of this article first appeared on The Anxious Bench, where she blogs regularly. It is used with permission. You can follow her on Twitter @bethallisonbarr.
Editor’s note: This is adapted from the original article that appeared Oct. 31, 2015.
Associate dean in the Baylor Graduate School, an associate professor of history at Baylor University and a resident scholar at Baylor’s Institute for Studies of Religion, where she specializes in medieval history, women’s history, and church history. She is the president of the Conference on Faith and History and is a member of Christians for Biblical Equality.