
On Friday, November 13, a federal court ruled that a church in Hermon, Maine, was illegally discriminated against when it was denied a long-term lease to hold services at the local high school. In his ruling, U.S. District Judge Lance Walker concluded that the district violated the church’s First Amendment rights and Maine’s public-accommodations law.
In late 2022, after renting space month-to-month from a local movie theater, Pines Church approached the Hermon School Department about a longer-term option. When its pastor, Matt Gioia, first contacted school officials about the possibility, the district’s superintendent responded favorably. In November, Gioia presented a lease proposal to members of the Hermon School Committee, who asked him several logistical questions but did not take a vote.
In subsequent days, one committee member asked Gioia via email to state the church’s positions on same-sex marriage, abortion, gender-affirming care, conversion therapy, sex education, and access to birth control. Gioia then asked whether the committee posed similar questions to other community groups seeking to lease space from the school district.
In December 2022, an attorney for the school district advised the Hermon School Committee that renting space to the church would not violate the First Amendment, but denying the lease because of the organization’s religious identity likely would. The attorney advised the committee to treat the church as it would any other community organization.
After procedural votes left the request for a yearlong lease unresolved, the committee offered the church a month-to-month arrangement, which it declined. Pines Church and Gioia filed suit against the district in May 2023.
In his ruling, Walker determined that the month-to-month offer was “designed to be rejected,” as the committee knew the church needed a stable, long-term arrangement before moving from its existing location. He found that religious animus influenced at least three of the committee’s five voting members.
Walker declared that the district had violated the church’s rights and awarded it $1 in nominal damages, along with reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. However, he declined to order the district to grant the church a lease or invalidate its facilities-use policy.
