Finding Common Cause on U.S. Refugee Programs

by | Nov 17, 2026 | Opinion

The hand of a refugee child holding a stuffed animal.
(Pressmaster/Canva)

The new Democratic-led Congress has an epically long to-do list. At the risk of getting overwhelmed by the competition, I humbly suggest an item that may actually have a chance, even over Trump’s veto.

Congressional leaders should restore Temporary Protected Status (TPS), at least for Haiti, Afghanistan and other countries still plagued by violence. Additionally, they should reconstruct the refugee system, which Trump has turned into a racist immigration program for white South Africans.

These are measures on which vocally Christian Democrats can build common cause with white evangelicals, or at least drive more of a wedge between them and Donald Trump.

It is within Congress’s purview to do this. The House has already passed a bill that would restore TPS for Haitians, who have been cruelly and unnecessarily targeted for deportation to what is essentially a war zone. The bill is now languishing in the Senate. The next Congress can reintroduce it, and with a projected 56 Senate seats (plus a fairly reliable vote in Lisa Murkowski), overcoming the filibuster is within reach.

Congress can also set a minimum for refugee admissions, something it has never done. The current law governing the refugee program allows the president to set only a maximum. Democratic Rep. Zoe Lofgren and Democratic Sen. Ed Markey introduced such a bill last year, but it remains stalled in committee.

For context, the U.S. admitted fewer than 17,000 refugees last fiscal year, down from more than 100,000 in 2024. All but five were white South Africans.


Common Cause

Why this issue? Unlike immigration in general, refugee resettlement has broad appeal among Americans writ large and, at least theoretically, among white evangelicals, Trump’s most loyal base.

Many of the Haitians being expelled are evangelical Christians themselves; the evangelical Southern Baptist Convention, the nation’s largest Protestant denomination, includes hundreds of Haitian churches. Many white evangelical churches have refugee ministries and have long engaged in refugee resettlement.

According to Lifeway Research, 70% of evangelicals believe the U.S. has a moral duty to admit refugees, whom the poll defined as people fleeing persecution based on race, religion, or political views. (2018 Pew polling, which did not define “refugee” for respondents, put the number for white evangelicals much lower, at only 25 percent.)

In addition, most evangelicals, who are intensely interested in Christian persecution around the world, would almost certainly be outraged to hear the administration admitted zero religious refugees last year. In my conversations, this isn’t well known, nor is Trump’s confinement of refugee admissions to white South Africans.

The math to override an almost certain Trump veto of these measures seems prohibitive. In the Senate, assuming all Democrats plus Murkowski vote in favor, ten Republicans would have to join them to override Trump’s veto.

In the House, Democrats have 256 seats, with ten seats outstanding. Let’s split the difference and give Democrats 261 seats, meaning they would need 29 Republicans to cross the aisle for an override. No doubt a steep hill to climb.

However, making a specifically religious appeal directly to white evangelical voters might put pressure on targeted senators and representatives, especially as Trump’s approval rating sinks. Democrats could do this in cooperation with evangelical organizations like World Relief and even Focus on the Family, which have already been outspoken on this issue.

In the Senate, Republican Senators James Lankford (Oklahoma), Mike Rounds (South Dakota), and Jerry Moran (Kansas) have previously been outspoken on refugee-related issues.

Senators Josh Hawley (Missouri), Ted Cruz (Texas), Ted Budd (North Carolina), and Pete Ricketts (Nebraska) have all been outspoken on Christian persecution in places like Nigeria. This raises the question of whether they support the administration’s de facto cessation of religious refugee admissions.

Budd is up for reelection in 2028 and Cruz in 2030 in states where Republicans just got annihilated, so they may be more eager to work with Democrats and differentiate themselves from Trump on a popular issue. Other senators and several House Republicans may be making similar calculations.


Focusing Attention

Even if Democrats ultimately failed to override Trump’s veto, the process would highlight an issue that I believe is the best potential wedge between white evangelical voters and the Republican Party. It would also build on Democrats’ explicitly religious appeal in 2026.

In my evangelical circles, refugee assistance is popular, and Trump’s pernicious, blatantly anti-Christian policies are not well known. Whether as a cynical political strategy or as a deeply humanitarian, moral imperative, Democrats should find time in their busy schedules to try.

Maybe their newly expanded cadre of Christian pastors and theologians can lead the way.